CO129-076 - Individuals - 1859 — Page 117

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Confess to be erroneous view the very compfect and of the facts which his reported speech presents, and on his lordship even then felt himself unable to found a satisfactory judgment

I saw nothing, my lord, in the Despatch of the present the 17 Despatch, which made necessary, denial of a copy or extracts, or the past Marit delay, devring several valuable months, to acquaint and with its tenor,

It was strictly confined to the mere criminatory charges, brought against me to the accused; viz: - those of bitter hostility towards inculpated officials, of refusing to sit on the bench of justice if the chief criminal sat there; - insubpect to my superiors, that is to say, to the late Governor, the late Lieutenant Governor, Secretary, when I accused them; - and the late Acting Colonial ... the bald words of accusation; - of presuming to address, to the Secretary of State, any appeal against the Governor, only, not the Governor thought fit to admit such appeal; - and of having failed to prove the main charge against the principal criminal, Mr. Caldwell, to the satisfaction of a Commission of Inquiry; nominated by the inculpated themselves, after my appeal to the Secretary of State had been presented, and, above all, after those officials had destroyed, with fire, the only proofs still extant, whereby, charge in question, that of having in connivance with his pirate-partner the convict Mah Chow Wong, endeavoured to deceive the Executive Council into the pardon of that convict) would have been proved.

Yet the Despatch expressly guards your predecessor from being understood to have formed any opinion, on anyone...

Page 77

1

114

...

C

D

Edit History

2026-05-18 15:07:33 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Confess to be erroneous view the very compfect and of the facts which his reported speech presents, and on his lordship even then felt himself unable to found a satisfactory judgment I saw nothing, my lord, in the Despatch of the present the 17 Despatch, which made necessary, denial of a copy or extracts, or the past Marit delay, devring several valuable months, to acquaint and with its tenor, It was strictly confined to the mere criminatory charges, brought against me to the accused; viz: - those of bitter hostility towards inculpated officials, of refusing to sit on the bench of justice if the chief criminal sat there; - insubpect to my superiors, that is to say, to the late Governor, the late Lieutenant Governor, Secretary, when I accused them; - and the late Acting Colonial ... the bald words of accusation; - of presuming to address, to the Secretary of State, any appeal against the Governor, only, not the Governor thought fit to admit such appeal; - and of having failed to prove the main charge against the principal criminal, Mr. Caldwell, to the satisfaction of a Commission of Inquiry; nominated by the inculpated themselves, after my appeal to the Secretary of State had been presented, and, above all, after those officials had destroyed, with fire, the only proofs still extant, whereby, charge in question, that of having in connivance with his pirate-partner the convict Mah Chow Wong, endeavoured to deceive the Executive Council into the pardon of that convict) would have been proved. Yet the Despatch expressly guards your predecessor from being understood to have formed any opinion, on anyone... Page 77 1 114 ... C D
Baseline (Original)
T Confess to be T erroneous view the very comperfect and of the facts which his which reported speech presents, and on his lendship even then felt himself unable to found a satisfactory judgment I saw nothing, my lord, in the Despatch of the pretent the 17 Despatch, which made necessary, tenial of a copy or extracts, or the past Marit delay, devring several valuable months, to acquirat and with its tenor, It was strictly confined to the mere noriminatory charges, brought against me to the accused; viz: - those of bitter : hodility towards inculpated officials,_ to sit on the beach of justice. of refusing if the chief criminal sat there ; _ " sinespect to my superiors, that is to in applying, say, to the late Governor, the late Licilement A Governer, Secretary, I when I accused them. _ & and the late Acting (olonial the ban words of accusation ; _ of presuming I address, to the bunitary of State, huy any appeal 1859. t 77 1 114 appeal against the Governor, unly, not the Governor thought fit to admit such appeal ; - and of havingfailed to prove the main charge agai the principal criminal, Mr. (aldwell, a Commission of to the satisfaction of Inguincy; nomenated by the inculpated themselves, after my appeal officials to the suntary of state had been presented, and, above all, after those officials had destroyed, with fire, the only pwops still extant, whereby, change in question, that of having in f with his pirate-partner connwance the the convict Mah (how Wong, endeacred to deceive the bxecutive Council into the pardon of that convict ) would have been proved. understood Yet the Despatch expreply guardes your predecessor from being to have formed any opinion, on anyoneg The کا 7 C D
2026-05-18 15:07:33 · Baseline
View content

T

Confess to be

T

erroneous view

the

very

comperfect and

of

the facts which his

which

reported speech presents, and on

his lendship even then felt himself

unable to found a satisfactory judgment

I saw nothing, my lord, in the

Despatch of the pretent the 17 Despatch, which made necessary,

tenial of a copy or extracts, or the past Marit

delay, devring

several valuable months, to

acquirat and with its tenor,

It was

strictly confined to the mere

noriminatory charges, brought against

me to

the accused; viz:

-

those of

bitter

: hodility towards inculpated officials,_

to sit on the beach of justice. of refusing if the chief criminal sat there ; _

" sinespect to my superiors, that is to

in applying,

say, to the late Governor, the late Licilement

A

Governer, Secretary, I when I accused them. _

&

and the late Acting (olonial

the ban words of accusation ; _ of presuming I address, to the bunitary of State, huy

any

appeal

1859.

t

77

1

114

appeal against the Governor, unly,

not

the Governor thought fit to admit such appeal ; - and of havingfailed to prove the main charge agai the principal criminal, Mr. (aldwell,

a Commission of to the satisfaction of

Inguincy; nomenated by the inculpated themselves, after my appeal

officials

to the suntary of state had been presented, and, above all, after those officials had destroyed, with fire, the only pwops still extant, whereby, change in question, that of having in

f with his pirate-partner

connwance

the

the convict Mah (how Wong, endeacred to deceive the bxecutive Council into the pardon of that convict ) would have been proved.

understood

Yet the Despatch expreply guardes your predecessor from being

to have formed any opinion, on anyoneg

The

کا

7

C

D

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.